Monday 24 June 2013

Comfort Challenge: Hammer vs Mfil300 vs Black Ace

After the overhaul of the hammer (link1)(link2) and mfil300 (link1)(link2), I was asked if I could pitch them against a Pro Kennex. 

I thought it made sense. Which is why I got the Black Ace 98 (link) to do this sinister comparion...

The hammer and mfil300 were strung with poly/syn gut and syn gut respectively. Some may argue it's an unfair competition, but I think the results should still hold and will be pretty fast and decisive.

Only my regular partner, M and myself would be doing the tests.

My objectives are to:

1. understand how an arm friendly racket ought to play like,
2. ascertain if a harsh racket can made to play arm friendly,
3. find out if my frequency based mod is repeatable,
4. satisfy our curiousity.


Hammer5.8Mfil300Black Ace 98
Strings
Poly Centre/Syn Gut perimeter
Syn Gut Full Proportional Stringing
Syn Gut Partial Proportional Stringing
Tension (lbs)
45/42
60
35
Length (inches)
27
27
27
Head Size (sq in)
95
98
98
String Pattern
16x19
16x19
18x20
Flex
65
61
58
Total weight (grams)
338
338
339
Balance (mm)
327
325
322
Sweetspot feel
9.5/10
8.5/10
6/10
Off-sweetspot feel
8.5/10
8/10
6/10
Sweetspot vibrations
Almost none
Very little
Clearly felt
Off-sweetspot vibrations
Almost none
Very little
Clearly felt
Power
8.5/10
7.5/10
6.5/10
Accuracy
9/10
8.5/10
7/10
Spin
7/10
8/10
8/10

No comments:

Post a Comment